Written by Fred Karlin and Dory Previn * Produced by Allen Stanton * Arranged by Nick DeCaro * 45: "Come Saturday Morning" / "Pretty Flamingo" * LP: Come Saturday Morning * Label: A&M * Billboard charts: Easy listening (#8), Hot 100 (#17) * Entered: 1969-11-15 (easy listening), 1969-12-20 (Hot 100)
More than a few listeners would likely be OK if those three scenes were all the movie contained, though, especially if the Sandpipers' lovely "Come Saturday Morning" (which climbed to #17 in 1970 and became an easy listening staple) is what drew them into it in the first place. The song features unambiguous lyrics by Dory Previn about a weekend-oriented relationship, a wistful melody by Fred Karlin, and the most sublime musical arrangement (courtesy of Nick DeCaro) the "Guantanamera" Sandpipers, a vocal trio from LA, would ever take part in. It's the song itself that gives those soft focus scenes an appropriately bittersweet context, and in his criticism, Ebert's tin ear is showing.
Without those scenes, all that's left is novelist John Nichols's not-so-inspiring story of two awkward college freshmen, Liza Minnelli's irritating chatter, and Burton's wishy-washiness. Those musical scenes really do help sustain the film and improve the odds of viewers sticking around past the mid-way point, at least. And in the present-day era, where pre-existing pop songs routinely appear as soundtrack filler, I honor films like The Sterile Cuckoo for commissioning songwriters to provide unique, story-enhancing material.
(Coincidence: The Sandpipers also performed the title track to the satirical film Beyond the Valley of the Dolls, which Roger Ebert co-wrote the screenplay for. The song appeared on the group's 1970 album Come Saturday Morning, named after the very hit single that accompanied The Sterile Cuckoo interludes Ebert disdained.)
The 1968 version of the Paul Williams-Roger Nichols tune "To Put Up with You" on side B (from Softly, a few albums previous—also arranged by Nick DeCaro) was an ideal aesthetic and contextual match for side A, and it must have been carefully selected, if not considered at one point for the soundtrack. (The hit version of "Come Saturday Morning" did not appear on Paramount's The Sterile Cuckoo soundtrack album.)
Side B: "To Put Up with You"